“Keeper”, another horror film from Osgood Perkins in last year besides “The Monkey” (2025), interested me at first, but then I found it rather underwhelming on the whole. Like many of Perkins’ previous works, it draws our attention with a subtle sense of anxiety at first, and that is certainly what we exactly expect from him. However, it ultimately feels bland and hollow due to its weak and deficient storytelling, and we come to observe the eventual moments of horror without much care.
After the opening montage scene which will certainly become more meaningful later in the story, the story begins with its heroine arriving with her boyfriend in some remote forest area where his little cabin is located. As she talks with a friend of hers on the phone, we come to learn that Liz (Tatiana Maslany) has been in a relationship with Dr. Malcolm Westbridge (Rossif Sutherland) for about a year, and she is certainly looking forward to having a nice private time with him in his cabin.
Needless to say, we cannot help but observe some little odd things about the cabin. For example, there is actually another cabin right next to the cabin, and, according to Malcolm, it belongs to a cousin of his. In addition, there is a rather suspicious gift box which turns out to contain a chocolate cake, and we come to have more suspicion when Malcolm deliberately makes Liz eat a piece of that cake during the following evening dinner, even though she does not like chocolate that much.
It also gradually becomes evident to Liz that there is something uncomfortable about the cabin and its owner. When she and Malcolm happen to be visited by his cousin, his cousin comes with some pretty foreign lady, and the mood becomes awkward due to his cousin’s rude words and behaviors, though he soon leaves along with his lady. On the next day, she somehow does not feel that right in her mind and body, and then she finds herself left alone in the cabin when Malcolm suddenly has to be absent for a while just because of one of his patients.
As Liz goes through a series of unnerving moments inside the cabin, the movie steadily builds up tension and uneasiness on the screen. The cinematography by Jeremy Cox remains mostly static and stable, but it subtly conveys to us more of the increasingly ominous atmosphere surrounding the heroine. We are not so surprised when the movie begins to reveal a bit more of whatever seems to be lurking somewhere inside the cabin, and there are several effective scenes where we see something happening right behind the heroine without being notice by her at all.
However, once the secret inside the cabin is eventually revealed during its second half, the movie becomes less interesting as losing much of its tension and suspense. Yes, we get to know a bit more about the long history of the cabin as expected, but that is delivered by a rather superficial expository scene. Furthermore, the screenplay by Nick Lepard does not seem to know what to do next, except providing us a lot of weird and grotesque things before arriving at its eventual ending.
Above all, the movie does not have much sense of fun. While it is pretty bleak and nasty to say the least, “The Monkey” sometimes tickles or horrifies us with its very dark and twisted sense of humor, and we can gladly go along with its diabolical fun. Compared to that, “Keeper” is relatively less enjoyable, even though it does have a few good moments which amuse us a bit with their deliberately gory aspects.
Nevertheless, the movie holds our attention to some degree thanks to the solid efforts from its lead actress. Tatiana Maslany, who previously collaborated with Perkins in “The Monkey”, is believable as her character is thrown into more isolation and paranoia along the story, and it is a shame that her good performance is often limited by her rather thin character. On the opposite, Rossif Sutherland, who is incidentally a son of Donald Sutherland, is unfortunately stuck with his thankless role, and the same thing can be said about Birkett Turton and Eden Weiss, who simply come and then go as required by the plot.
In conclusion, “Keeper” is a dissatisfying misfire which leaves us with growing empty impression in the end, and that is surprising considering how Perkins has steadily impressed us with his modest but interesting genre films. I admired “I Am the Pretty Thing That Lives in the House” (2016), and “Gretel & Hansel” (2020), and I also liked “Longlegs” (2024), which has many enjoyable things besides Nicholas Cage’s deliciously unhinged villain performance. In case of “The Monkey”, it shows that Perkins can be a bit more humorous in his own way, and I still remember how biting it is to the end.
Anyway, Perkins keeps going as usual at this point. Besides participating the production of “Backrooms” (2026), he has already been working on his next film to be released in this year, and it surely draws some attention due to several notable cast members including not only Maslany but also Johnny Knoxville and Nicole Kidman (Now that is an interesting combination). Although I was disappointed in this time, I sincerely hope that Perkins will satisfy me more in the next time, and that is all I can say for now.













































