Netflix film “Voicemails for Isabelle”, which was released a few weeks ago, is quite typical to the bone. Even before its Meet Cute moment, you will already have a pretty good idea on how the story will go after that narrative point, and it will not surprise you much on the whole. Nevertheless, its many conventional aspects are thankfully compensated by a number of enjoyable things including the undeniable likable presence of its lead actress, who is certainly the best element in the film.
Zoey Deutch, who has been more prominent during last several years thanks to her good performances in several notable films such as Richard Linklater’s “Nouvelle Vague” (2025), plays Jill Shaw, a struggling young female baker working in San Francisco, California. During the opening part, we see how close Jill and her younger sister Isabelle (Ciara Bravo) were to each other as they grew up together, and the movie handles this crucial part with enough humor and poignancy. Although Isabelle had been struggling with cystic fibrosis since her birth and was not expected to live that long, Jill always stood by her along with their loving parents, and Isabelle certainly appreciated her older sister’s care and affection.
Although Jill subsequently left their home in Austin, Texas for her baking career, she and Isabelle keep corresponding with each other day by day. When Isabelle tells Jill on one day that her current medical condition has been getting worse than before, Jill is not particularly worried at first, but then her younger sister suddenly dies not long after that, and Jill is certainly quite devastated by this sudden loss.
After going through another unsatisfying day not long after Isabelle’s death, Jill leaves a voicemail to Isabelle’s phone number as usual, but it turns out that Isabelle’s phone number is now for a new smartphone belonging to Wes (Nick Robinson), a hunky lad incidentally working as a real estate broker in Austin. While he is quite perplexed by the continuing stream of voicemails from Jill, Wes gets to know more about her and Isabelle via her voice mails, and he eventually decides to go to San Francisco for meeting her.
Because he knows where she usually sends her voicemail to him, it is not difficult for Wes to meet Jill at that spot in question. Although he still does not talk anything about receiving her voicemails, Ned comes to like Jill more as getting to know her more during next several days, and Jill is pleased to spend more time with Wes, who seems to be much better than several crummy dudes she met before him.
Yes, this surely feels quite conventional already, and the screenplay by director/writer Leah McKendrick is certainly well aware of that. At one point in the middle of the story, Wes confides everything to his two best friends who are about to marry, and they immediately point out that his situation is not so far from Tom Hanks’s character in “You’ve Got Mail” (1998) – and how unfair he is to Jill just like Hanks’s character to Meg Ryan’s in that movie. In addition, a number of romance films such as “The Faults in Our Star” (2014) are mentioned throughout the movie, and it is a shame that “Vertigo” (1958), which is, in my humble opinion, one of the most desperate (and morbid) romance films in the movie history, is not mentioned at all even though the Golden Gate Bridge is frequently shown in the film.
McKendrick’s screenplay mostly sticks to its numerous genre conventions, but it mixes them with a substantial amount of wit and humor, and the result is often buoyed by her two engaging lead performers. Deutch frequently exudes her natural charm as her character bounces from one narrative point to another along with her co-star, and she also demonstrates well her considerable comic talent during several key scenes associated with her abusive boss and rather unsympathetic colleagues. While having some good laughs from that, we come to care more about Jill than before, and Deutch diligently carries her character and the movie to the end even though the story lags more than once during the last act.
On the opposite, Nick Robinson, who has mostly been known for his several notable films including “Love, Simon” (2018), is relatively bland compared to his co-star. Nevertheless, he is well-cast as an effective counterpoint for Deutch, and he has his own moment when his character valiantly attempts to amuse and entertain Jill and several others riding a local tour bus along with them. We can clearly sense more of the growing affection between them, and that certainly makes him more hesitant about revealing everything to her than before.
In case of several supporting performers in the film, they simply fill their functional roles as much as possible. As Jill’s sick younger sister, Ciara Bravo clicks well with Deutch during the early part of the story, and Gil Bellows and Tanis Dolman provide some warmth as Jill and Isabelle’s caring parents. Harry Shum Jr. and Megan Danso have some fun with their broad supporting roles, and Nick Offerman gleefully chews his several scenes as Jill’s abusive boss.
Overall, “Voicemails for Isabelle” does not break any new ground in its genre territory, but it works mainly thanks to the solid chemistry between Deutch and Robinson. Even though I found their movie a bit too predictable, I still rooted for their characters nonetheless, and that is what a good romantic comedy film can do, isn’t it?













































