“The Choral”, which is currently available on Netflix in South Korea, is a mildly somber period drama about one little choral performance during wartime. Although it feels meandering at times due to its rather thin and unfocused narrative, the movie works to some degree at least when it eventually arrives at the expected finale where the efforts of its main characters are finally and dramatically demonstrated in front of others.
Set in a fictional town in Yorkshire, UK, 1916, the story begins with a big trouble in the local choral society in the town. When its choirmaster happens to join the army due to the ongoing war in Europe, its members quickly look for someone to replace their former choirmaster, and that happens to be Dr. Henry Guthrie (Ralph Fiennes). Although he is deemed rather problematic due to several reasons including atheism, they eventually agree to recruit him because he seems to be the best option for them right now.
While he is not so willing to take the job at first, Dr. Guthrie accepts the request, and he surprises the elder members of the choral society a lot right from his first day. Once it is clear that the choral society needs more male voices due to the absence of many former male members who went to the war, he willingly recruits more male singers besides a number of new female singers. In addition, he does not care much about class background from the very beginning, so the choral society is packed with various figures from the town ranging from a young Salvation Army lady to a middle-aged woman of some seedy reputation.
And then there comes the matter of what the chorus will perform for the upcoming local concert. They initially chose a certain famous work by Johann Sebastian Bach, but they later decide that it is inappropriate just because Bach is a German. Eventually, they choose “The Dream of Gerontius” by British composer Edward Elgar instead after it is suggested by Dr. Guthrie.
Because they have a rather short time for their practice, Dr. Guthrie and his chorus members must do their best, but then he becomes quite frustrated as his chorus members often do not reach his standard. Fortunately, they come to show some improvement as time goes by, and Dr. Guthrie also comes to have an idea on how to elevate their performance more. He wants the performance to reflect the horror and sadness of the ongoing wartime, and he subsequently has a number of injured soldiers join the chorus.
Meanwhile, we get to know a bit more about Dr. Guthrie along the story. Although he is a quiet and reserved man, it has been known well that he is gay, and some people in the town often regard him with suspicion just because he lived in Germany for many years before the war began. Nevertheless, he keeps focusing on his job as usual, and this professional dedication of his is appreciated more by the chorus members.
The movie also pays some attention to several subplots involved with a number of key members of the choral society. In case of a wealthy local Alderman, his private life has been desolated after he lost their only son to the war, and we observe a lot of estrangement between him and his grieving wife. In case of a young woman whose boyfriend went to the war several months ago, she has been quite worried as he was possibly dead, but then her heart is drawn to one of the chorus members, who is soon conscripted to the army just like many other lads around his age.
The screenplay by Alan Bennett, who previously collaborated with director/co-producer Nicholas Hytner in “The History Boys” (2006) and “The Lady in the Van” (2015), tries to juggle these and many other story elements together, but the result is superficial and scattershot at times as not providing enough narrative momentum to engage us more. As simply moving on from one episodic moment to another, the story frequently struggles to hold the center, and it also fails to provide enough depth and substance to its several subplots, all of which are conveniently resolved around the finale as expected.
At least, Ralph Fiennes is engaging in his quietly sensitive performance, which speaks volumes even when his character does not seem to express much on the surface. While being mostly unflappable throughout the story, Fiennes gradually conveys to us his character’s thoughts and feelings without showing them off at all, and one of his best moments in the film comes from when Dr. Guthrie has an honest private conversation with his accompanist at one point in the middle of the story. The accompanist, who is incidentally gay just like Dr. Guthrie, decides to be a conscientious objector instead of getting conscripted to the army, and Dr. Guthrie is saddened because there is no possible way for him to help his accompanist at all.
On the whole, “The Choral” is a bit too mild to hold my attention, and I wish it did more groundwork before eventually arriving at the expected finale. Yes, the finale will not disappoint you at all as its main characters give a choral performance to remember, but the movie is often hampered by its weak storytelling, so I ended up admiring their performance from the distance. They surely did a good job, but the movie itself is rather underwhelming in my inconsequential opinion.







































