
“Whalefall” is a terrifying survival drama mostly unfolded inside a big whale, and it does its job better than I expected. When I watched its trailer several weeks ago, I wondered whether the movie can actually work in terms of story and character, but, what do you know, it turns out to be an effective genre piece whose sheer intensity and thrill compensate for a number of artificial aspects in the film.
At the beginning, the movie quickly establishes its story premise. After the suicide of his father who has struggled with his terminal illness for a while, its young hero, Jay Gardiner (Austin Abrams), returns to his seaside hometown, and we soon sense his unresolved daddy issues. As shown from a series of flashback scenes along the story, he and his father Mitt (Josh Brolin) were not so close to each other mainly because Mitt was your average macho dude, and Jay cannot help but become haunted more by what happened during their last time not long before his father’s death.
While not communicating that much with his other family members including his mother Zara (Elisabeth Shue), Jay eventually decides to find wherever the body of his father is at present. Mitt committed suicide via letting himself sunk beneath a certain spot in the sea, and Jay is quite determined to retrieve any part of his father’s body, just because he wants to prove his will and courage to himself as well as his father.
Of course, once he goes into the sea, it turns out that Jay is woefully unprepared for his personal mission, and then there comes a very unexpected happening upon him. Shortly after he happens to encounter a big giant squid, a huge sperm whale suddenly appears, and it eventually swallows not only that squid but also Jay, who unfortunately gets himself caught by the tentacles of that squid at the last minute.
After this scary and intense underwater action sequence which will hold you on the edge of your seat, the movie will impress you more as our unlucky hero subsequently finds himself at a certain spot not so far from the whale’s stomach. Mainly thanks to the fluorescence from one stingy jellyfish, this frequently claustrophobic space is not totally dark at least, but I must tell you that it is relatively dimmer than my endoscopy video shot in last year.
Needless to say, there is not much time for Jay as his oxygen is running out minute by minute, but he only finds himself cornered in one way or another. The screenplay by director Brian Duffield and his co-writer Daniel Kraus, which is based on the novel of the same name written by Kraus, steadily doles out a series of perils along the story. As a guy who studied biology during his college and graduate school years, I certainly winced when Jay makes an unwise choice of going further along the digestive tract of the whale, and the movie has some nasty fun during the following gory moments.
As getting more despaired and frustrated along the story, Jay’s mind often goes back to those personal memories of his father. While these flashbacks incidentally lead him to several impromptu survival strategies, the body of the whale turns out to be quite a mighty opponent, and the movie does a good job of presenting this big animal with considerable awe and terror. While I am sure that a lot of CGI is incorporated into many key scenes unfolded inside the whale, its innards look quite convincing on the screen, and, without feeling too stuffy or limited at all, the cinematography by Aaron Morton conveys well to us the increasingly palpable sense of claustrophobia surrounding our hero.
The last act of the story feels utterly preposterous in addition to being blatantly sentimental, and I must confess that I rolled my eyes a bit while observing more plot contrivances along the story. Nevertheless, the movie manages to hold our attention even at this point thanks to Duffield’s competent direction, and you may become willing to overlook some mawkish touches around this point.
It goes without saying that the movie depends a lot on the presence and talent of its lead actor. Austin Abrams, who has been on the way of becoming another new interesting actor to watch thanks to his solid performances in Zach Cregger’s two recent films “Weapons” (2025) and “Resident Evil” (2026), willingly throws himself into a lot of acting challenge here in this film, and his committed acting ably holds the center while his rather pathetic character gradually finds his inner strength along the story. In addition, you will be also amused to observe him coping a lot with tentacles again just like he previously did in “Resident Evil”.
With Abrams at the center, many of the other notable cast members in the movie simply fill their respective spots without much impression. Josh Brolin, who seems quite ready to take over the flawed male characters usually reserved for Nick Nolte, brings some intensity to several flashback scenes in the film, but these scenes unfortunately interrupt the main narrative more than once to our distraction. In case of Elisabeth Shue, John Ortiz, Jane Levy, and Emily Rudd, they are sadly limited by their under-developed supporting roles, though I mused a bit on how much time has passed since Shue and Brolin appeared together in Paul Verhoeven’s “Hollow Man” (2000).
Overall, “Whalefall” is tense and entertaining enough to overcome its several glaringly weak aspects including that clichéd father and son relationship in the story. As leaving the screening room, I amused myself a bit as wondering whether a seafood dish inspired by this movie is possible, but I also admitted to myself that I was really thrilled and terrified more than once, and that says a lot about its effectiveness in my humble opinion.












































