Uberto Pasolini’s 2024 film “The Return” is a grim, shabby, and bitter tale based on the second half of Homer’s “The Odyssey”. Unlike Christopher Nolan’s new film “The Odyssey” (2026), the movie does not have much action or spectacle on the whole, and it mostly focuses on the brooding mental struggle of a traumatized man barely recognizable even to his family after his long-awaited return. This may look like an interesting retelling attempt on Homer’s classic story on the surface, but you may be disappointed to see that the result turns out to be somewhat flat and ponderous despite the fairly good efforts from its two lead performers.
The main background of the story is a Mediterranean island named Ithaca. Around 10 years have passed since the end of the Trojan War, but Odysseus (Ralph Fiennes), the king of Ithaca, has not returned yet, and almost everyone in the island has presumed that he died. Nevertheless, his wife Penelope (Juliette Binoche) still believes that he will eventually return someday, though there have been a bunch of dudes eager to marry her for getting the control of the island.
As these suitors have not only ruined the island but also cornered his mother in one way or another for years, Odysseus’s young son Telemachus (Charlie Plummer) has been quite frustrated to say the least. He also hopes for his father’s return, but the situation becomes all the direr for him and his mother day by day, and he becomes more conscious of what may happen to him if she ever chooses to marry one of those suitors.
Unbeknownst to Telemachus and his mother, Odysseus has already been in the island as shown from the opening scene of the film, but he hesitates to return to his wife and son as still coping with his post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). While he may be relieved to be at the end of his returning journey, he does not feel like belonging to his good old home, and he often struggles with not only those dark memories of the war but also how much he has changed after many years. In fact, he is not so sure whether he can be recognized by his wife and son.
Meanwhile, the story becomes a bit tense as those ambitious suitors keep trying to coerce Penelope into marrying one of them. No matter how much she tries to stand her ground in front of these loathsome dudes, Penelope often finds herself trembling behind her supposedly unflappable appearance, because, well, she is not entirely free from her own human need as reflected by one certain moment in the middle of the story.
As Odysseus continues to brood over what to do next, we often observe the harsh and brutal aspects of his world, and this certainly reminds us more of how vulnerable his wife and son can be under their increasingly desperate situation. Needless to say, he must take some action for them sooner or later, but he is still reluctant, and then there comes an eventual moment when he sees that there is really no alternative for him at all.
However, while occasionally showing some interesting storytelling potential, the screenplay by Pasolini and his co-writers John Collee and Edward Bond often struggles to maintain our attention. As getting mired in more misery and brutality, the story merely lurches from one expected narrative point to another without generating much interest to engage us, and it is also hampered a lot by its rather superficial characterization. For example, it just scratches the surface in case of Telemachus’ supposedly deep daddy issues, and that is the main reason why his sudden choice around the end of the story is not so convincing to us. Furthermore, the movie resolves all those evident emotional issues between Odysseus and his wife a bit too easily after the climatic sequence where he takes care of all those suitors (Is this a spoiler?), and that is another disappointment in the film.
Anyway, Ralph Fiennes and Juliette Binoche, who previously performed together in “Emily Brontë’s Wuthering Heights” (1992) and “The English Patient” (1996), remind us again that they are two of the best movie performers in our time. Fiennes, who also served as one of the executive producers of the film, did a good job of conveying to us a heap of trauma and guilt behind his character’s shabby appearance, and he is especially compelling when his character reminisces a bit about what he witnessed during the Trojan War. On the opposite, Binoche is usually required to look stern or frustrated throughout the film, but she has her own moment when Penelope faces how much her husband has changed after all those years around the end of the climactic sequence.
In case of several other notable main cast members in the film, they are sadly under-utilized due to their under-developed supporting part. Although he has shown some considerable talent since his breakout supporting turn in “All the Money in the World” (2017), Charlie Plummer somehow looks rather lost and strained compared to his fellow cast members including Tom Rhys Harries, Claudio Santamaria, and Marwan Kenzari, and Kenzari deserves some praise for bringing a bit of human depth to his villainous supporting role.
In conclusion, “The Return” is a little too disappointing for me to recommend, but you may be interested in checking it out someday due to “The Odyssey”. Just like Nolan did in that film, Pasolini simply tries to do something different with Homer’s familiar classic story, and it is a shame that his result did not impress me enough.













































