“Moana”, which is a live-action remake version of 2016 Disney animation film of the same name, feels so thoroughly redundant from the beginning to the end that my mind frequently went stray here and there while I watched it at a local movie theater today. In fact, I was so bored and distracted that I actually welcomed the occasional chatters among the four little young boys sitting right next to me. They might have annoyed some audiences around them to some degree, but, what the heck, their chatters had a lot more life than whatever I observed from the screen.
And I must confess that I was also quite tempted to copy a lot of my 3-star review on the 2016 animation version. For describing a bit of the story and characters to you here within a minute, all I would have to do is copying and then pasting several paragraphs from that review of mine, though I would also have to change the names of the cast members except one certain member.
Yes, Dwayne Johnson, who provided the voice of Maui in the 2016 animation version and its following 2024 sequel, returns here to play the live-action version of his character, and all I can tell you is that he still has all the right stuffs for playing Maui as before. While he certainly has no problem in looking as bulky and muscular as required, he effortlessly brings some likable jolliness to his shapeshifting demigod character, and he surely lightens up the mood when he delivers that certain well-known musical number as expected.
However, as we all know, the center of the story is a young plucky girl named Moana (Catherine Laga’aia), who is a member of some Polynesian island tribe who has been governed by her village chief father for years. While her father prefers to maintain the status quo on their island as much as possible, Moana, who will succeed her father someday, has been aspiring to explore whatever is beyond their island, and her aspiration is gently encouraged by her father’s eccentric mother.
When the life on the island becomes quite endangered by some unknown dark force, Moana naturally tries to find any possible solution besides merely enduring that as her father suggests. Thanks to her grandmother, she comes to learn that her tribe actually sailed around here and there outside their island a long time ago, and this discovery eventually prompts her to sail beyond the island with a certain magical object which may be the key to restoring her world.
Of course, not long after she departs along with her wacky pet chicken, Moana eventually encounters Maui, who has been stuck in a small rocky island for many decades after he inadvertently caused that grave ongoing harm on Moana’s world. Although he is not so willing to help her at first, Maui eventually agrees to help Moana, and they soon go through several risky moments before eventually arriving at their destination.
The following action sequences during the second half of the film are mostly slick and competent, but they only remind me more of why live-action film can rarely surpass animation. For example, we can easily accept Moana’s pet chicken as a supporting character right from the start in case of the 2016 animation version, but we often cannot help but notice it as a mere CGI figure in case of the 2026 live-action version, and the same thing can be said about that giant crab character, which is voiced again by Jemaine Clement here in this film. Although Clement has some fun again with his delightfully vain monster character, his musical scene in the film feels less colorful and inspired in comparison, and that is another disappointment in the movie.
The overall quality of the soundtrack of the film is fairly good on the whole, but they are more or less than the adequate reproduction of the soundtrack of the 2016 animation version. The score by Mark Mancina and the songs by Mancina and his two collaborators Lin-Manuel Miranda and Opetaia Foaʻi are mostly fine here, but I must point out that most of its highlights depend on the previous materials from the soundtrack of the 2016 animation version. While Miranda provides a new song for the end title of the 2026 live-action version, I do not think it will linger on your mind as long as that Oscar-nominated song of the 2016 animation version.
Anyway, the overall result is not a total dud at least mainly thanks to the earnest lead performance from newcomer Catherine Laga’aia, who imbues her titular role with enough spirit and personality just like Auli’i Cravalho did in the 2016 animation film version. In case of several supporting performers in the film, John Tui and Frankie Adams bring some gravitas to the story as Moana’s caring parents, and Rena Owen, a New Zealand actress who is mainly known for “Once Were Warriors” (1994), steals the show during her brief appearance.
In conclusion, “Moana”, directed by Thomas Kail, is thankfully not as awful as I feared, but it still feels quite unnecessary as doing almost nothing except merely reproducing what was so enjoyably presented before. Folks, we already had to endure the passable live-action version of “Lilo & Stitch” (2002) and “How to Train Your Dragon” (2010) in last year, and now here comes a more redundant product my mind will soon forget without much regret. Like many of you, I have really been quite tired of these and many other pointless cases of live-action remakes during last several years, and I can only wish that there will soon come the end of this undeniably wasteful trend.








































![[Explore 20260711] Roof [Explore 20260711] Roof](https://live.staticflickr.com/65535/55387098748_81a5288818_s.jpg)




