Benny Safdie’s new film “The Smashing Machine” is mildly unconventional as often being deliberately subdued and anti-climactic in terms of narrative. This can be considerably frustrating to you at times, but it is somehow held together by the admirably committed efforts from its lead actor, who flexes a surprising amount of acting muscle here in this movie.
Dwayne Johnson, who often looks quite different here thanks to the recently Oscar-nominated makeups by Kazu Hiro, Glen Griffin and Bjoern Rehbein, plays Mark Kerr, a real-life American Mixed Martial Arts (MMA) fighter who was very famous during the 1990-2000s. The opening part shows Kerr having one of his career moments in 1997, but then we see how things have been rather messy in his life and career. Just for staying more in his field, he has frequently depended on painkillers, and his resulting addiction brings another strain on his troubled relationship with his girlfriend Dawn Staples (Emily Blunt), who tries her best but always ends up being not so supportive to her boyfriend.
And things get only worse for Kerr when he later goes to Tokyo for an international competition he is going to participate with the assistant of his close friend/colleague Mark Coleman (Ryan Bader). During his first round, Kerr’s physical condition happens to be not very ideal because of another heavy dose of painkiller, and this eventually leads to a humiliating moment of defeat, though he saves his face to some degree thanks to a little violation of his opponent during the match.
Not long after this painful time of defeat, Kerr arrives at a certain inevitable point familiar to any addict who has ever hit the bottom and then had a real moment of recognition. With some sincere support from Coleman, Kerr comes to admit that he does have a serious problem to face and then deal with, and that is the beginning of his first step toward sobriety, though this is not so easy for him as he comes to clash more and more with Dawn.
In the end, Dawn decides to leave Kerr, and Kerr comes to focus on more sobriety as well as preparing for comeback. He sets his eyes on winning the champion title at the same competition in Tokyo in 2000, and we see him diligently going through a series of training sessions under Bas Rutten, an ex-MMA fighter who is incidentally played by himself in the movie.
Meanwhile, Coleman also begins to go back in action. As showing much better match results than expected, he is also going to participate in that Tokyo competition in question, but both he and Kerr keep supporting each other as usual, even though being well aware of the growing possibility of confronting each other in the big final match.
However, the screenplay by Safdie, who also edited the film besides serving as one of its co-producers, curiously does not attempt to build much dramatic tension on this. As a matter of fact, several key match scenes in the film are presented in a rather perfunctory fashion instead of generating more intensity to grab our attention, and we often find ourselves observing the story and character from the distance as merely following a series of comments from the sportscasters in the movie.
This may disappoint you if you expect something as intense or propulsive as what Safdie and his older brother Josh Safdie achieved in “Good Time” (2017) and “Uncut Gems” (2019), but the movie still works as an engaging character study supported by those small but genuine emotional moments observed from Kerr and several other characters around him. Johnson, who also participated in the production of the film, really pushes himself much more than ever as immersing himself deep into the role virtually tailor-made for him considering his professional wrestling career, and he and Ryan Bader, who is also undeniably perfect for his role due to his real-life professional MMA career, are constantly believable during several key scenes between them. Right from their first scene, you can clearly sense the deep and strong sense of friendship and comradeship between their characters, and you may wish that the movie would focus more on their characters’ enduring relationship.
In contrast, the movie sadly stumbles whenever it tries to depict Kerr and Dawn’s increasingly problematic relationship. Regrettably stuck in a very thankless supporting role, Emily Blunt is seriously wasted on the whole, and the movie fails to give us any clear understanding on the apparently toxic aspects of her character’s relationship with Kerr, which only brings out the worse sides of theirs despite their supposedly sincere efforts.
In conclusion, “The Smashing Machine”, which incidentally won the Silver Lion award for Best Director when it was premiered at the Venice International Film Festival in last year, is one or two steps down from what Safdie impressively achieved along with his older brother in their previous films, but it is not wholly without entertainment mainly thanks to his competent direction and his lead actor’s diligent acting. I do not know whether he will work with his older brother again, but he demonstrates here that he can go his way fairly well just like his older brother recently did in “Marty Supreme” (2025) in the same year, and it will be interesting to see how their respective filmmaker careers will diverge or converge during next several years.













































