“The Sheep Detectives” has much more charm and wit than its rather silly title suggests, and I was accordingly entertained a lot during my viewing. As a comic mystery tale mixed with some familiar elements from Agatha Christie as well as “Babe” (1995), the movie often intrigues and delights us from the beginning to the end, and it even shows some genuine poignancy as its animal detective characters delve more into their simple but urgent murder case.
The story, which is set in a typical English country village which will surely take you back to Christie’s Miss Marple stories, opens with how wonderful things have been for a bunch of sheep under the care of their shepherd George Hardy (Hugh Jackman). George is a nice dude who deeply cares about the sheep under his charge, and the early part of the movie shows how he goes through his daily life alone by himself with his sheep.
One of George’s daily routines is reading mystery novels to his sheep just for comforting and entertaining them a bit before they go to sleep. Unbeknownst to him, his sheep actually understand whatever he reads aloud in front of them, and we get an amusing moment when they actively discuss later on who committed the murder in the latest mystery novel read to them.
Meanwhile, things get rather ominous in the village. It looks like George is not liked that much by some of the villagers, and we observe some fishy aspects of these villagers. What do you know, he is soon found dead outside his little residence by his sheep on the next morning, and his sheep are naturally quite devastated as feeling quite uncertain about what may happen to them.
In case of a sheep named Lily (voiced by Julia Louis-Dreyfus), she gradually senses that there is something suspicious about Geroge’s death, and she and her friend Mopple (voiced by Chris O’Dowd) eventually decide to investigate more on their shepherd’s death. Not so surprisingly, there are indeed several possible suspects in the village, and the situation becomes a bit more complicated when George’s daughter, who was incidentally separated from him when she was very young, arrives at the village along with her no-nonsense lawyer and George’s will.
I must say that the mystery inside the story is rather elementary to my standard (I could easily and instantly spot a small but crucial clue which soon led to me to the identity of the murderer, for example), but I was constantly engaged thanks to the witty screenplay by Craig Mazin, which is based on the 2005 German mystery novel “Three Bags Full” by Leonie Swann. As smoothly juggling its numerous animal and sheep characters, the movie deftly doles out one possible clue after another to be picked up by us and our sheep detectives, and it is fun to see how they show more wit and intelligence as trying to figuring out what really happened to their dear shepherd.
In addition, they also show a lot more sincerity than expected as becoming more serious about the case and their life. In case of a sheep named Sebastian (Bryan Cranston), he is rather aloof even when he gives some help to Lilly and Mopple, but he turns out to be hiding a lot of personal pain involved with his past before being bought by George. As a sheep which can remember much more than other sheep, Mopple certainly has some serious issues to deal with, and there is a little touching moment when he confides to Lily a bit on the upside and downside of his unique ability.
It surely helps that the sheep characters in the movie are convincingly realistic enough for us. Although they are mostly CGI, many of them look individually distinctive for their colorful appearances and personalities, and they become more endearing to us as they diligently carry the story toward the finale where everything is revealed and explained. While she looks mostly plain on the surface, Lily is clever and resourceful enough for not only solving the case but also finding a rather ingenious way to deliver the answer to a local police officer struggling to handle the case, and that incidentally takes me back to that cat detective in Jiro Akagawa’s several mystery novels including “A Game of Cat and Killer”.
The voice cast members in the film did a splendid job of bringing enough life and personality to their respective woolly roles. Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Bryan Cranston, and Chris O’Dowd ably balance their sheep characters between humor and drama, and several other voice cast members including Regina Hall, Patrick Stewart, Bella Ramsey as Zora, and Brett Goldstein have each own moment to shine. In case of the performers playing the human characters in the story, Hugh Jackman, Nicholas Braun, Nicholas Galitzine, Molly Gordon, Tosin Cole, Hong Chau, and Emma Thompson bring extra fun to the story without never overshadowing the sheep characters in the story at all, but Thompson steals the show a bit as expected to our little delight.
In conclusion, “The Sheep Detective”, directed by Kyle Balda, is certainly recommendable for anyone who loves good mystery novels. Considering that Swann subsequently wrote two sequel books after “Three Bags Full”, we may soon get another adventure of these likable woolly fellows, and I will certainly have some expectation if the production of the sequel is started.













































