Jeffrey Manchester is someone who can be described as a “nice bad man”. While he was a pretty resourceful armed robber who robbed a bunch of franchise stores without much remorse, he was also actually quite nice and considerate to those unfortunate people held at his gunpoint. As a matter of fact, everyone who ever encountered him does not say anything bad about him, even though they probably all agree that he deserves his eventual prison sentence.
His absurd real-life story is certainly a rich comedy material, but I don’t think Derek Cianfrance’s latest film “Roofman” succeeds in its rather mild mix of comedy and drama. As a drama, it does not have much depth in terms of storytelling and characterization, and we only come to observe it from the distance with some amusement. As a comedy, it is occasionally funny mainly thanks to the natural charm of its leading actor, but its attempts on absurdity are often dulled by several weak aspects including its leisurely narrative pacing.
The early part of “Roofman” succinctly establishes how Manchester, played by Channing Tatum, begins his criminal career in 1998. When he needs some money for buying a real nice birthday gift for his dear daughter currently living with his ex-wife, he decides to rob a local McDonald’s fast food restaurant, and, what do you know, he turns out to have all the right stuffs for being an armed robber. As a former US Army non-commissioned officer, he has a particular set of skills including a very keen ability of observation, and these skills certainly help his following criminal spree a lot, which incidentally earns him that silly nickname from his usual method of breaking and entering.
Needless to say, there comes an inevitable point where he is arrested by the local police after robbing around 40 fast food restaurants, but Manchester is not so daunted even when he gets sentenced to 45-year imprisonment. While keeping himself on the line in the prison, he slowly and carefully plans an escape just because he wants to see his daughter again, and the movie has some fun with how he prepares for his wily escape plan step by step without any suspicion from others.
While he succeeds in escaping from the prison in the end, Manchester soon comes to see that approaching to his daughter or his ex-wife is not a wise thing to do to say the least. He decides to evade the following police search for a while before finding a possible way to get out of the country, and he comes upon a fairy suitable place for his hiding: a local Toys “R” Us store.
The screenplay by Cianfrance and his co-writer Kirt Gunn works best when its hero comes to show more resourcefulness as beginning to live inside this local toy store without being noticed by anyone. At first, he just hides above the ceiling, but then he discovers a hidden space in the middle of the story, which becomes his secret shelter. While he has to be very careful about those security cameras, he soon finds a way to turn off their recording mode, and he even sets up his own little security cameras for his own safety.
Meanwhile, Manchester begins to pay attention to Leigh Wainscott (Kirsten Dunst), one of those store employees who is also a single mother with two daughters. As watching how she struggles to balance herself between work and raising her daughters, Manchester comes to care about her, and then he eventually approaches to her as “John Zorn”, a supposedly new neighbor who happens to attend a nearby church associated with her. Although he does not say much about himself or his job, it does not take much time for him to charm her, and he soon gets more involved with not only her but also her two daughters.
There are several humorous moments including the one when Manchester comes to have a very pleasant meeting with Wainscott and several other female churchgoers, but the story is often hampered by its uneven mix of comedy and drama. When things expectedly become more serious during the last act, the movie comes to lose its remaining comic momentum, and the following dramatic moments feel contrived without enough gravitas in advance.
Furthermore, the movie somehow lacks the chemistry between Tatum and his co-star. While Kirsten Dunst is certainly a talented actress, she and Tatum seem to be on autopilot without generating much sense of mutual attraction, and her efforts are often undermined by her under-developed character. In case of Tatum, he ably wields his natural comic talent at times, but he is also frequently limited by the weak screenplay just like he was in “Fly Me to the Moon” (2024).
I am also quite dissatisfied with how many recognizable performers in the film are wasted in one way or another. LaKeith Stanfield, Juno Temple, Peter Dinklage, Ben Mendelsohn, Uzo Aduba, Emory Cohen, and Tony Revolori are just demanded to fill their respective spots around Tatum and Dunst, and Dinklage, who usually steals the show in many movies during last several years, is particularly under-utilized as Wainscott’s cranky boss.
On the whole, “Roofman” is not entirely humorless, but it is not entertaining enough for me to recommend it. I appreciate that Cianfrance goes for something lighter after making “Blue Valetine” (2010) and “The Light Between Oceans” (2016), but he stumbles a bit too much here, and I still think it could be funnier and edgier in many aspects. Yes, Manchester is indeed an interesting guy with a pathologic criminal tendency, and this dude’s truly preposterous real-life story deserves something better than this in my inconsequential opinion.













































