Craig Brewer’s latest film “Song Sung Blue” is a bit too conventional to my little disappointment. Probably because I am already familiar with its dramatic real-life story, the movie often felt to me like being no more than a merely dramatized version, and that is a shame considering the good efforts shown from its two engaging lead performers.
The movie is based on the 2008 documentary of the same name by Greg Kohs, which incidentally won the Jury and Audience Awards for Best Documentary at the Sundance Film Festival but has somehow been forgotten since that. I had a fortunate opportunity to watch this little but special documentary at the 2010 Ebertfest, and I still remember how much I and many audiences enjoyed it and then were entertained by the following Q&A and the singing from Claire Sardina, who is the main human subject of the documentary with her late husband Mike (She is still alive at present, by the way).
The story begins with how these two singers happened to come across each other in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, 1987. At that time, Mike (Hugh Jackman) worked as a Don Ho impersonator, but he was not so happy about his current impersonation job, and then he met Claire (Kate Hudson), who was doing a Patsy Cline impersonation at that time. Despite their first brief encounter, they quickly become close to each other, and then Claire suggested that he should try on Neil Diamond, mainly because many of Diamond’s songs mean a lot to him.
While initially being reluctant because he has respected Diamond a lot, Mike gradually comes to see the potential of success, and he and Claire soon find themselves clicking with each other a lot more than expected. While he nicknames himself “Thunder”, Claire becomes “Lightning”, and we subsequently see how they and several colleagues of his including Mark Shurilla (Michael Imperioli) prepare together inside the stuffy garage of Mike’s house.
Needless to say, their first attempt to present themselves in public is a disaster to say the least, but Mike and Claire are not daunted at all. After some more advice from her, Mike agrees to make a bit of compromise for making their performance a little more accessible, and then, what do you know, they become more and more popular as days go by.
Meanwhile, we get some glimpse into their rather complicated private life. Both Claire and Mike married once, and it takes some time for Claire’s two kids to get accustomed to a man who will be their new daddy. When Claire’s daughter later meets Mike’s daughter, they naturally feel rather awkward, but then there comes an amusing moment as they find that there are a lot of common things between them as two girls who had to grow up faster due to the human flaws of their respective parents.
Thanks to their growing popularity in Milwaukee, Mike and Claire are asked to do the opening for Eddie Vedder and his rock band Pearl Jam, they certainly feel like being at the top of the world, but then, of course, there comes an unexpected accident not long after they did that opening. Shocked and devastated by her consequent injury and disability, Claire tumbles into the downward spiral of depression and drug addiction, and Mike tries to support her as much as possible along with their kids, while hiding his worsening heart problem behind his back.
Around this narrative point, you can easily see where Brewer’s screenplay is heading, and it will probably not surprise you that much. Yes, there come several dark personal moments as Mike, Claire, and their kids struggle more and more due to Claire’s medical problem. Yes, there eventually comes the point where Claire manages to pull up herself and then comes to have a surprising moment of catharsis and healing via a truly incredulous happening (Believe or not, this really occurred in real life). Yes, she and Mike subsequently get back in business and then there comes another high point for their career as expected.
We are supposed to be moved more along the story, but, alas, the movie does not go further than all these and other conventional moments in the story. In addition, the movie also feels rather superficial in case of its several supporting characters around Mike and Claire, and it under-utilizes a number of notable performers Michael Imperioli, Fisher Stevens, and Jim Belushi.
Nevertheless, its two lead performers are fairly engaging as carrying the film together to the end. While Hugh Jackman, who has been one of the best musical actors of our time, is certainly dependable during those well-executed musical performance scenes in the film, Kate Hudson, who finally has a role as juicy as her Oscar-nominated role in Cameron Crowe’s “Almost Famous” (2000), ably complements her co-star besides having her own moments to shine, and she was recently Oscar-nominated for that.
On the whole, “Sing Sung Blue” is less satisfying compared to Brewer’s previous works such as “Hustle & Flow” (2005) and “Dolemite Is My Name” (2019), and I must confess that my mind kept going to a number of genuine human moments in Kohs’ documentary – including that intensely painful scene between Claire and her son. In this very typical musician biographical film, there is nothing as raw and honest as that unforgettably emotional moment, and maybe you should look for that documentary instead.













































